Publication date: October 2026
A supplier can answer “yes” to every question on a sustainability questionnaire and still receive a low rating. The reason is almost always the same: the claims aren’t supported by evidence the evaluator will accept.
This article explains how three questionnaires commonly received by Mexican suppliers are scored—the automotive industry’s SAQ 5.0, EcoVadis, and CDP—and provides a practical checklist to help suppliers prepare the evidence each one expects before responding.
The questionnaire is completed in an afternoon. The quality manager, who inherited the task because “she handles customer matters,” answers all 25 questions with the information at hand. Environmental policy? Yes. Environmental management system? Yes, certified. Code of conduct? Yes. Sustainability requirements for suppliers? Yes, they’re in the purchasing procedure. She attaches a few files and submits the questionnaire.
Two weeks later, an email arrives from the platform: evidence gaps have been identified. The policy doesn’t specify which topics it covers. The ISO 14001 certificate that was uploaded is for a plant in another city. Training was documented with a screenshot from the company intranet. Supplier requirements don’t appear in any contracts. The final rating is two letter grades below what the company expected.
Nobody lied. The plant has a policy, a system, a code, and a procedure. What it didn’t have was evidence in the form the evaluator accepts.
In the previous article, “Nearshoring and Environmental Certifications: ISO 14001, EcoVadis, and SBTi—Three Steps on the Same Ladder,” we proposed a five-level maturity scale for organizing ISO 14001, EcoVadis, and Science Based Targets initiative goals. This article brings that scale down to the day-to-day experience of suppliers: the questionnaire.
Mexican suppliers serving global customers most often receive three questionnaires:
The three questionnaires have different formats, but they share the same logic: they score what can be demonstrated with acceptable evidence. And they all ask, in different words, about many of the same things. That’s good news, because one well-organized evidence base can support all three.
SAQ is the common questionnaire developed by Drive Sustainability, an alliance of automakers coordinated by CSR Europe. It was created in 2014, and version 5.0 was published in 2022. Sixteen member automakers now use it so suppliers don’t have to complete a different questionnaire for every customer. In 2025, it was adjusted for nonproduction suppliers: depending on their activities and number of employees, some questions are optional.
A note on its origins: SAQ predates the German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (Lieferkettensorgfaltspflichtengesetz, or LkSG), passed in 2021 and effective since 2023. However, version 5.0 was aligned with the law. The questionnaire asks companies to appoint a human rights officer and clarifies that, for companies subject to the LkSG, this is the officer required by law. It also asks about grievance mechanisms and risk assessments as part of due diligence. It specifically asks whether the company reports annually on its compliance with legal due diligence obligations, “for example, the German LkSG.” For automakers subject to this law, SAQ is one of the tools they use to document due diligence across their supply chains. As a result, when a Mexican supplier completes it, its evidence becomes part of its customer’s legal compliance records.
The questionnaire is organized into seven sections: company management, human rights and working conditions, health and safety, business ethics, environment, responsible supply chain management, and responsible sourcing of raw materials. It is completed for each site where production takes place, not just for corporate headquarters.
On the platform used to administer it, the questionnaire moves through three stages:
The supplier answers the questions and uploads evidence.
A team checks whether each document meets the acceptable evidence criteria for that question. If the evidence doesn’t meet the criteria or support the selected answer, a gap is recorded.
The supplier receives its rating, a list of identified gaps, and recommendations for improvement. It can then update its responses.
The supplier receives its rating, a list of identified gaps, and recommendations for improvement. It can then update its responses.
The results include two indicators. The minimum-scope rating is a letter grade that measures performance on mandatory questions only: A (100%), B (80–99%), C (60–79%), D (40–59%), E (20–39%), and F (0–19%). The sustainability score measures performance across the full questionnaire, including optional questions. Both are compared with the country and industry averages.
One important nuance: each buyer may also conduct its own assessment of a supplier’s response.
The SAQ 5.0 rating methodology assigns a weight to each response. Understanding those weights changes how companies should prepare for the questionnaire.
Three findings stand out:
Answering “yes” to having a policy earns no points by itself. For policy questions, an affirmative answer alone doesn’t increase the score. Points depend on the topics the policy covers and whether employees receive training on it. A generic one-page policy earns only a fraction of what a policy would earn if it listed emissions, energy, water, chemicals, waste, and biodiversity—and included training records.
Management systems are the backbone. Three certified systems—environmental, health and safety, and human rights—can account for up to 30% of the rating. An implemented but uncertified system retains between half and three-fifths of that value. That’s why ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 remain the best initial investments for a supplier.
Some questions don’t earn points but still influence decisions. The percentage of renewable electricity, emissions reduction targets, SBTi validation, Scope 3 targets, and CDP rating don’t count toward the SAQ 5.0 score. But buyers still review them. These are exactly the data they need for their own climate strategies, and each customer can include them in its own assessment. Here’s the important part: a response that doesn’t earn points in SAQ may still matter to the customer.
CDP operates a global environmental disclosure system. For a Mexican supplier, the process usually starts when a customer enrolled in CDP’s supply chain program sends a request to respond. SAQ 5.0 confirms this trend: it includes a full question about the supplier’s current CDP rating for climate, water, and forests, including the rating year.
Here are some features of the 2026 cycle to keep in mind:
CDP groups ratings into four levels: Disclosure (D and D-), Awareness (C and C-), Management (B and B-), and Leadership (A and A-). There’s also an F, given to companies that were asked to respond but didn’t. The customer that sent the request can see the F rating. For a supplier, ignoring a customer’s request is the worst possible outcome—worse than receiving a D for incomplete but honest information.
The most efficient way to prepare isn’t to answer each questionnaire separately. It’s to build a shared evidence base and reuse it. The table shows how the topics align.
The checklist accompanying this article turns that table into an eight-part checklist. Each item identifies the evidence an evaluator expects and the corresponding level on the maturity scale.
The checklist takes about an hour to complete and provides an initial assessment: which areas are strong, which have the practices but lack evidence, and which are not yet in place.
Imagine a plastic injection molding plant in Querétaro that is a Tier 2 supplier to the automotive industry. It has had ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 for years. It receives its first SAQ 5.0 and gets a D on the minimum-scope rating.
The gap report tells a different story. The environmental policy existed, but it didn’t list the topics it covered. The ISO 14001 certificate that was uploaded was the corporate certificate and didn’t specify the site’s scope. Training had taken place, but there were no attendance records. The restricted substances procedure covered only safety data sheets and didn’t mention restrictions in destination markets. Supplier requirements were in an internal procedure, not in contracts.
None of those gaps required building a new system. The company needed to organize the evidence its existing system already produced. In its next update, the plant improved its rating by two letter grades. It also discovered that half of the evidence could be reused for its first EcoVadis assessment.
Let’s go back to the email about the gaps. What it really said was that the plant had a functioning system but didn’t know how to communicate it. In a global supply chain, if a buyer can’t verify something, it doesn’t exist to them.
Evidence doesn’t replace practice: a perfect file describing a practice that doesn’t exist will fall apart during the first on-site audit. But having the practice without evidence isn’t enough either. That’s what the checklist is for: so that when the next questionnaire arrives, the system can speak for itself.
Don’t leave your rating to chance or put automaker contracts at risk because of rejected documents. Our PDF checklist helps you audit your eight evidence areas before submitting the questionnaire.
What is SAQ 5.0?
It is the automotive industry’s common sustainability self-assessment questionnaire, developed by Drive Sustainability. It assesses company management, human rights, health and safety, ethics, the environment, supply chain, and raw materials. It is completed for each site, and the evidence is validated before a rating is issued.
How is SAQ related to the German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act?
SAQ was created in 2014, before the LkSG, but version 5.0 was aligned with the law. It asks companies to appoint a human rights officer, establish a grievance mechanism, conduct risk assessments, and report annually on due diligence obligations. Manufacturers subject to the law use SAQ to document due diligence across their supply chains.
How is SAQ 5.0 scored?
It uses two indicators: a minimum-scope rating from A to F based on mandatory questions, and a sustainability score based on the complete questionnaire. Certified management systems, supplier requirements, and the code of conduct carry the greatest weight.
Will my CDP rating or SBTi-validated targets raise my SAQ score?
No. These questions don’t carry weight in the SAQ 5.0 methodology. However, customers review the information and may include it in their own assessments because they need it to meet their climate targets.
If I already have an EcoVadis rating, do I still need to complete SAQ?
It depends on what your customer requires. They are different tools, but much of the evidence is the same. An organized evidence base makes it much easier to complete both.
¿Por dónde empiezo?
Start with legal compliance and management systems, which are the foundation for everything else. The checklist helps identify which areas have the practices in place but lack evidence; those are often the quickest to improve.
Todos los Derechos Reservados 2026